When is it against platform rules or a bad idea to offer an incentive for a customer review?

Money & Running the Business

When is it against platform rules or a bad idea to offer an incentive for a customer review?

The short answer

Never offer money, discounts, gifts, entries, or other benefits on the condition that a review be positive. On Google, incentives for posting, changing, or removing reviews are prohibited. Even where a platform allows an incentive for any honest review, disclosure and consumer-protection rules may apply.

The safest small-business practice is simple: ask real customers for honest reviews without paying them.

Three rules can apply at once

You need to check:

  1. the review platform’s current policy.
  2. federal, state, local, or national advertising law.
  3. your own wording and selection process.

A campaign can violate a platform rule even if a law would permit it, and it can be deceptive even if the platform does not catch it.

Google’s review guidance says offering free or discounted goods or services in exchange for customers posting, changing, or removing reviews is prohibited. That makes “Leave a Google review for 10 percent off” a poor plan, even if you say the review may be honest.

Sentiment-conditioned incentives are prohibited federally

The FTC’s Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule Q&A explains that an incentive cannot be expressly or implicitly conditioned on positive or negative sentiment. “Tell us how much you loved it and get $5” is not rescued by calling it feedback.

The FTC also notes that an incentive offered for any review can create disclosure obligations. State and other national rules may add requirements, so check the law where you operate and where you invite customers.

Don’t review-gate

Review-gating means sending happy customers to a public review site while routing unhappy customers into a private form. Ask for private feedback if you want it, but don’t use the answer to decide who is allowed to reach the public review link. The FTC’s guide to soliciting reviews advises businesses not to ask only customers they expect will leave positive feedback.

Use a neutral trigger instead, such as every completed order, every closed service ticket, or a random sample of verified customers.

Separate reviews from referrals and surveys

You can thank customers for a private survey or run a referral program, subject to applicable rules. Be precise about what you are rewarding. If the reward is really for a public review, calling it a “survey bonus” does not change the substance.

Example of a cleaner referral offer:

Refer a new customer. If she makes a qualifying purchase, you both receive the stated credit. No review is required.

Disclose referral relationships where a recommendation could be viewed as advertising.

Audit any campaign before launch

Save the exact invitation, landing page, platform policy, incentive terms, eligibility rule, and disclosure. Have a qualified local attorney review campaigns involving money, regulated industries, or many customers.

If an old campaign offered rewards for positive reviews, stop it, preserve the records, and get advice before trying to “fix” the reviews yourself.

Sources and further reading

A free next step

You don't have to build this alone

Bring your questions, share what you're working on, and meet other women building businesses from home. It is free to join.

Join Our Community Free

Related Questions

← All questions